The scary world of work capability tests

Over the next three years 1.5 million people currently claiming incapacity benefit will undergo the work capability assessment to see if they are fit to work. Soon 1,000’s of people will be receiving letters asking them to attend work capability assessments. Yet, the test has been vigorously criticised by charities such as Citizens Advice and by a government-commissioned independent review, saying that the process is impersonal, and ill-equipped to gauge the seriousness of mental health conditions, or complex medical problems.

On Monday the Commons Work and Pensions Committee held an open meeting in Burnley, to hear the views of people who have actually undergone the new work capability test. A report in the Guardian newspaper gives a powerful account of what the Committee heard and it wasn’t good.

“I just seemed to be a number. The health professional didn’t know what one of my conditions was,” one man said.

“My wife scored zero points,” another said. “The test was a total waste of time; it was all physically orientated, nothing about her mental state. They asked things like ‘Can you brush your teeth?’ How that relates to mental health issues is beyond me. It was overthrown at tribunal. I can only describe it as mental torture; she was a mental wreck after it.”

Paul Hogarth, from the local Citizens Advice Bureau, argued that the test was not fit for purpose, frequently declaring people with serious health conditions fit for work. The advice centre had supported many people to tribunals, 80% of whom had seen the assessor’s decision overturned, he said.

Kevin Nuttall, a welfare rights adviser working with Action for Blind People in Lancashire, said he had supported someone through a test which concluded that he had “mild visual impairment” and was fit for work. “He was in fact registered blind,” he said.

Others highlighted the long wait for appeals to be heard, and the impact. “I am waiting for a tribunal, but I’m told that it won’t be before June, because there are so many people waiting. I’m stuck on the £65 benefit until then,” a woman with ME said, and began to cry.

The chair, Dame Anne Begg said she was concerned about the speed with which the reform was being pushed through: “Personally, I see there are serious problem with the WCA. My view is that either they should be slowing down the national rollout or speeding up the implementations of changes to the system”


One response to “The scary world of work capability tests

  1. Couldn’t agree more – In Gateshead CAB Annual report for 10/11 they note that:

    “One of the common threads is the extremely low income that clients have to suffer for long periods while they are appealing standard benefit decisions. The appeal process is invariably over 6 months and sometimes 12 months or longer.

    For example, clients last year appealing an Incapacity Benefit/Credits decision that they were fit for work would be entitled to a reduced rate
    of Income support amounting to £52.36 / week.

    Out of this £10 gas and £10 electric meter charges are average amounts. This leaves £32.36/week

    Water rates are at least £6/wk and many clients have to make up a shortfall of rent which is at least £5/wk. This leaves £21.36.

    A payment for a basic TV licence is £3.50 leaving £16.36.

    If the remainder is divided by 7 it gives a daily figure of £2.33 a day which has to cover everything else, including food and drink, clothes, travel expenses etc. This position can continue for 6-12 months.

    The impact on someone with significant mental health problems is obvious and can only be a barrier to recovery and maintenance of good physical and mental health.”

    Mark Gamsu

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s